So disappointed in your product.
Response from leathermagic.com
I am sorry to hear our standard Cognac furniture color did not match your Haverty's cognac color. This is unfortunate and a common issue as furniture companies do not all use the same color dye lots. So even though there are hundreds of furniture companies all with the pieces dyed in a "cognac" color, they will all be different shades. We offer our custom color matching services for this reason. We can directly match to your swatch and guarantee the color will match your sample. There is nothing in the dye to remove color; however if you have applied the leather prep to surrounding areas this will remove some color as it is designed to prepare the surface. If you would like to send us photos we will gladly take a look and help in any way we can.